It feels like summer just got here and already we are fast approaching back to school. I know this not because I have children, but because we've been inundated for almost two weeks now with back to school sales fliers and commercials. Every retail store, from big-box to department stores, grocery stores to dollar stores, even some hardware stores, are vying for the big dollars of the back-to-school business. Apparently students now NEED new clothes, fancy school supplies, brand-name backpacks, new desks, laptops, coordinating dorm room asscessories from well-known interior designer, mini-appliances in the hot new colors... not too long ago, we purchased $.15 notebooks, a pack of pens and pencils, and a box of Kleenex and off we went. We got new shoes and backpacks about every-other-year, and we rarely even got new clothes...
Yes, you read that right, we didn't get new clothes every year. No trendy Z-Cavaricci pants and Girbaud tops (blessing in disguise if you ask me..). We had school uniforms. My brother and I went to a very poor inner-city school that instituted school uniforms when I was in fourth grade, my brother in first, in order to minimize the expense of school clothing and make the economic status of our classmates less apparent. At first we hated it, all the students did. My best friend transferred schools because if it. We all whined and rebelled, parents complained about the initial cost, students complained because we would all look the same (the irony was lost on us that we all tried, to the best of our abilities, to dress the same anyway). I had one jumper, a couple pairs of navy and black pants, five or six white tops, and two sweaters. No labels or logos allowed. The first month was rough, it was weird seeing my classmates in the same clothes everyday. Teachers had a hard time learning names when everyone was dressed the same.
It was amazing how quickly everyone adapted. I loved getting dressed in the mornings now, it was so easy to pick out my clothes. My brother got ready a lot quicker, since him and my mom didn't have to go around and around on what clothes were school appropriate, now he just put his uniform clothes on. My class no longer broke off into groups of the "haves" and the "have-nots" in terms of clothing and trendy items. We still complained, but we complained less about the uniforms than we did about the lax dress code we had previously.
Our clothes lasted longer, we didn't get bored with them and uniform clothes were often better quality than their trendy counterparts. We had clothing swaps several times a year at school for parents to bring their kid's outgrown clothing, and to trade for new used clothing. No one knew if you were wearing new or used, since all your clothes, and everyone else's, looked the same. I had one uniform skirt that lasted from 6th-8th grade, the fabric was so durable we used to write on our skirts on the bus and the ink always came out in the wash.
We got to know each other better because we weren't making assumptions about others based on their clothing. Some people argue that uniforms stifle creativity, but I think it's the opposite, they encouraged us to be ourselves, since our clothing was no longer speaking for us.
7 comments:
Great post, Savvy. I really enjoy your blog.
I just took the kids to get school supplies the other day. I think all together we spent about $110. We buy clothes at the end of the season, in advance of the next year. We save a bundle doing it that way.
I can't decide whether or not I like school uniforms. On the one hand, it does take away the "status symbols" that regular clothes provide. I remember growing up wanting to have the clothes that the "rich" kids had. But, I didn't get them and I made it through just fine.
I think we all have to realize that there are different ecomonic classes. There always will be.
Personally, I think we try too hard to protect our kids. Eventually, they have to grow up.
That's my $.08 (adjusted for inflation!).
JLP
AllThingsFinancial
PS - I just wanted to add that I don't think society places as much emphasis on clothes now days. There are lots and lots of people getting cheaper clothes at Target.
JLP
I'm guessing the society as general doesn't mind as much (or as much as before), BUT in school, things gets a bit rough. Kids arent exactly the nicest people in the world, sometimes. I'm sure these days, kids in middle and high school still care highly about what they wear. If that wasn't the case, Addias wouldn't be buying Reebox to compete with Nike. Nor would they lose in the first place in the casual shoe category. Here's what a WSJ got from some mid 20s guy: "Addias, it's good for runners.. but not o profile in. People wear Jordans (Air Jordan, from Nike) to look cool."
Great post too. I never thought of school uniforms as a way to equalize things a bit. I always associate them with private school etc.
But yeah JLP points out some good stuff, to protect or not. Personally I think in certain situations, like inner city.. it may be an issue and school uniform might not be such a bad idea. I know we're all getting off topic, but one of the problem with school is the fact popularity matters, and it affects a lot of kids. They have enough to worry about, they shouldn't also have to worry about looking "cool," dressing the latest fashion (whatever it is), etc.
One thing all of my friends notice, is that when you hit college, it starts to matter less (what you wear, that is).
If you were in highschool, and you're wearing something from.. say Mervyn's, poeople would probably snicker/laugh at you. But if you're in college, and you wear something from Mervyn's.. people would probably realize why, cuz money starts to matter more.
Anyway, that's a whole other topic. lol.
My dd wore school uniforms a few years ago (went to a Christian school) and I thought they were great. I wish my school district would implement that idea here.
This post has been added to the Carnival of Personal Finance #8!
I like the concept of uniforms at school. It is something like telling kids: Dress to Learn.
I once read on some inspirational book that you should "Dress for the Dance". The analogy was that when you go out with friends to some party or to the theater
you do dress in a particular way (otherwise, shorts, t-shirt, and flip flops would be appropriate everywhere).
By the same token, dressing for business (something that clearly states that you will be serious) can help you put into a state of mind to work more seriously. And I do not mean using ties and suits... just dressing like you mean business.
By the same token, if a kid dress like he means school it may put him/her on a state of mind that it is time to learn... not to play.
When they get back to home they go back to regular clothes and it may be time for other ventures.
Just another point of view on which you can agree or disagree.
Money and Investing
I had a professor in college that used to strongly encourage us to dress up for tests. He wanted men to wear at least a shirt and tie, suit if possible, and women were to wear skirts or dress slacks and a nice top. His theory was that his students performed better on tests when they were dressed for success. I still carry that forward. I dress up for work when I know I will have a challenging day ahead of me.
Post a Comment