Given that people who invest in Savings Bonds and other Treasury securites are looking for an investment with as little risk as possible, several of TreasuryDirect's policies are pretty scary. You've discovered one of them.
Another is that they don't notifiy you if any of the details of your account are changed, for example, the associated bank account or your address. This kind of notification is a standard security practice for financial companies such as brokerage firms or mutual fund companies.
Another is that Regulation E doesn't apply to Treasury Direct. This is the banking regulation that says if a thief gets your credit card number, your liability is limited.
If a thief gets your TreasuryDirect details, changes the bank account, and cashes in your funds, you likely won't know until months later when you receive the 1099-INT tax form telling you how much interest income you earned. Meanwhile, the Treasury is adamant that it will not cover your losses.
I've brought these issues up with my contacts at the Treasury, but the conversations always end the same way. If you aren't willing to take the risk, don't use TreasuryDirect.
Comments on "Government bonds - not as safe as you think?"
-
Penny said ... (11:17 AM) :
-
jay said ... (12:08 PM) :
-
Anonymous said ... (10:33 PM) :
-
Steve said ... (11:42 PM) :
-
Anonymous said ... (3:14 PM) :
-
mapgirl said ... (5:01 PM) :
-
Dan said ... (4:57 PM) :
-
Anonymous said ... (7:32 AM) :
post a commentOkay, you've officially scared me. As soon as my year is up, I am cashing in my I-bonds. I was going to anyways--it seems like they won't earn much for the next 6 months--but now I have more reason. Plus, I'm kind of worried that if there were some kind of financial, or other, disaster, such as China pulling all its U.S. bonds, there might be a run on cashing in bonds and the government, debt-laden as it is, might not be able to pay everyone back. I'm going to stick with CDs from now on.
The same scenario concerned me one time, but after doing some reading it wasn't so bad.
Countries are not going to try to cash in so much that the US cannot repay. What good do those bonds do them if it makes the US government go bankrupt?
It's in their best interest not to intentionally hurt the US economy.
two points -
first one - i have some i-bonds and the site has all of your financial info available if anyone gets in there. more so, i have noticed, then other financial sites i have - i.e. - fidelity, etc. - and, of course, it is the government, so the customer service is lackluster. i'm not a big fan.
anyway, 2nd point, on the plus side - i think if it ever got to the point that you couldnt cash a govt.bond - you and the country have much more serious banking issues to worry about. like national bank insolvancy, etc. - there wouldnt be a safe place to put $ anywhere.
Don't worry, if there is a run on bonds (or the banks) the Fed will just fire up the printing press and produce as many dollars as are needed... ;)
how you can invest is an entity which has a debt ceiling of $9,000,000,000,000 is beyond me. My citizenship is exposure enough to this insolvent nation.
Fascinating. That doesn't seem very consumer protection worthy of our government. Where's Eliot Spitzer to ferret out the problem and change the state of things?
Treasury Direct actually is not *AS* unsafe as it sounds in that article.
As posted farther down on that Savings-Bond-Advisor thread, the article had missed the fact that Treasury Direct *DOES* now send an e-mail notification about account changes. (This relatively recent upgrade was likely thanks to online discussions like these!)
It does trouble me, however, that if anyone did manage to get ahold of my Treasury Direct user ID and password, they would have access to all of my linked bank account numbers. I wish T.D. would only display the last four digits as other financial institutions do.
Until they change that, my personal response to this shortcoming is:
(1) don't keep any accounts linked to TD for which I haven't scheduled transactions
(2) log on once a week to keep an eye on the account
(3) never log in on a public PC or anyone's PC you're not sure is secure (like my Limewire-using friends)
(4) keep my home computer as secure as possible
(5) Do an extra "paranoid dance" when typing my Treasury Direct password, in hopes that it might evade any simple keyboard logging spyware that may have made it's way to my computer. I usually copy/paste part of the password from a separate file.
Has anyone tried to add a bank account that is not yours (a family member) to test if it will be flagged as an error?